Riddler problems

The forum for general posting. Come join the madness. :)
Post Reply
Message
Author
User avatar
Bob78164
Bored Moderator
Posts: 21626
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 12:02 pm
Location: By the phone

Riddler problems

#1 Post by Bob78164 » Fri Jan 12, 2018 8:08 pm

I'm pretty sure I've figured out this week's Riddler Express. The Riddler Classic appears to be more of a challenge.

The Riddler Express: Fix a circle. Choose three points at random (uniform distribution) on the circle. (To be clear, that's on the circle itself, not in its interior.) Those three points form a triangle. What is the probability that the center of the circle lies within the triangle? My answer:
Spoiler
0.25
.

The Riddler Classic: Fix a sphere. Choose four points at random (uniform distribution) on the sphere. (To be clear, that's on the sphere itself, not in its interior.) Those four points form a tetrahedron. What is the probability that the center of the sphere lies within the tetrahedron? I don't think the technique I used to figure out the Riddler Express generalizes to this case. --Bob
"Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blindfolded fear." Thomas Jefferson

User avatar
mrkelley23
Posts: 6260
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 6:48 pm
Location: Somewhere between Bureaucracy and Despair

Re: Riddler problems

#2 Post by mrkelley23 » Fri Jan 12, 2018 9:39 pm

Bob78164 wrote:I'm pretty sure I've figured out this week's Riddler Express. The Riddler Classic appears to be more of a challenge.

The Riddler Express: Fix a circle. Choose three points at random (uniform distribution) on the circle. (To be clear, that's on the circle itself, not in its interior.) Those three points form a triangle. What is the probability that the center of the circle lies within the triangle? My answer:
Spoiler
0.25
.

The Riddler Classic: Fix a sphere. Choose four points at random (uniform distribution) on the sphere. (To be clear, that's on the sphere itself, not in its interior.) Those four points form a tetrahedron. What is the probability that the center of the sphere lies within the tetrahedron? I don't think the technique I used to figure out the Riddler Express generalizes to this case. --Bob
I don't think the uniform distribution constraint applies to the Express puzzle. Otherwise, I think the probability would be 1.00.
For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled. -- Richard Feynman

User avatar
Bob78164
Bored Moderator
Posts: 21626
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 12:02 pm
Location: By the phone

Re: Riddler problems

#3 Post by Bob78164 » Fri Jan 12, 2018 10:13 pm

mrkelley23 wrote:
Bob78164 wrote:I'm pretty sure I've figured out this week's Riddler Express. The Riddler Classic appears to be more of a challenge.

The Riddler Express: Fix a circle. Choose three points at random (uniform distribution) on the circle. (To be clear, that's on the circle itself, not in its interior.) Those three points form a triangle. What is the probability that the center of the circle lies within the triangle? My answer:
Spoiler
0.25
.

The Riddler Classic: Fix a sphere. Choose four points at random (uniform distribution) on the sphere. (To be clear, that's on the sphere itself, not in its interior.) Those four points form a tetrahedron. What is the probability that the center of the sphere lies within the tetrahedron? I don't think the technique I used to figure out the Riddler Express generalizes to this case. --Bob
I don't think the uniform distribution constraint applies to the Express puzzle. Otherwise, I think the probability would be 1.00.
Definitely not. Consider any three points in the upper half of the circle, which obviously occurs with probability greater than zero. The triangle they form definitely doesn't include the center of the circle. --Bob
"Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blindfolded fear." Thomas Jefferson

User avatar
Bob Juch
Posts: 26427
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 11:58 am
Location: Oro Valley, Arizona
Contact:

Re: Riddler problems

#4 Post by Bob Juch » Fri Jan 12, 2018 11:57 pm

Bob78164 wrote:I'm pretty sure I've figured out this week's Riddler Express. The Riddler Classic appears to be more of a challenge.

The Riddler Express: Fix a circle. Choose three points at random (uniform distribution) on the circle. (To be clear, that's on the circle itself, not in its interior.) Those three points form a triangle. What is the probability that the center of the circle lies within the triangle? My answer:
Spoiler
0.25
.

The Riddler Classic: Fix a sphere. Choose four points at random (uniform distribution) on the sphere. (To be clear, that's on the sphere itself, not in its interior.) Those four points form a tetrahedron. What is the probability that the center of the sphere lies within the tetrahedron? I don't think the technique I used to figure out the Riddler Express generalizes to this case. --Bob
Express: You are correct.
Classic:
Spoiler
1/8
I may not have gone where I intended to go, but I think I have ended up where I needed to be.
- Douglas Adams (1952 - 2001)

Si fractum non sit, noli id reficere.

Teach a child to be polite and courteous in the home and, when he grows up, he'll never be able to drive in New Jersey.

User avatar
mrkelley23
Posts: 6260
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 6:48 pm
Location: Somewhere between Bureaucracy and Despair

Re: Riddler problems

#5 Post by mrkelley23 » Sat Jan 13, 2018 9:45 am

Bob78164 wrote:
mrkelley23 wrote:
Bob78164 wrote:I'm pretty sure I've figured out this week's Riddler Express. The Riddler Classic appears to be more of a challenge.

The Riddler Express: Fix a circle. Choose three points at random (uniform distribution) on the circle. (To be clear, that's on the circle itself, not in its interior.) Those three points form a triangle. What is the probability that the center of the circle lies within the triangle? My answer:
Spoiler
0.25
.

The Riddler Classic: Fix a sphere. Choose four points at random (uniform distribution) on the sphere. (To be clear, that's on the sphere itself, not in its interior.) Those four points form a tetrahedron. What is the probability that the center of the sphere lies within the tetrahedron? I don't think the technique I used to figure out the Riddler Express generalizes to this case. --Bob
I don't think the uniform distribution constraint applies to the Express puzzle. Otherwise, I think the probability would be 1.00.
Definitely not. Consider any three points in the upper half of the circle, which obviously occurs with probability greater than zero. The triangle they form definitely doesn't include the center of the circle. --Bob
If all three points are in the upper half of the circle, then they are by definition not "uniformly distributed." That's why the classic uses the words "uniformly distributed" and the Express does not.
For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled. -- Richard Feynman

User avatar
Bob78164
Bored Moderator
Posts: 21626
Joined: Mon Oct 08, 2007 12:02 pm
Location: By the phone

Re: Riddler problems

#6 Post by Bob78164 » Sat Jan 13, 2018 2:40 pm

mrkelley23 wrote:
Bob78164 wrote:
mrkelley23 wrote:
I don't think the uniform distribution constraint applies to the Express puzzle. Otherwise, I think the probability would be 1.00.
Definitely not. Consider any three points in the upper half of the circle, which obviously occurs with probability greater than zero. The triangle they form definitely doesn't include the center of the circle. --Bob
If all three points are in the upper half of the circle, then they are by definition not "uniformly distributed." That's why the classic uses the words "uniformly distributed" and the Express does not.
Uniform distribution refers to the probability distribution. It's a more precise way of saying that each point is equally likely (which isn't a helpful concept for continuous probability distributions because the probability of any specific point being selected is 0). Uniform distribution (in this context) means that the probability that your randomly selected point ends up in a given arc is the ratio of the length of that arc to 2*pi.

An alternative, for instance, would be that points are twice as likely to end up in the lower semicircle than in the upper semicircle. --Bob
"Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blindfolded fear." Thomas Jefferson

Post Reply